Fiber Laser Cutting vs. Traditional Sheet Metal Cutting Techniques

From: 本站 Date: 03rd September 2021 Author: shengangtong Views: 1469

If manufacturing your product requires cutting a shape out a sheet metal, you will face several processing options. Some factors to consider when evaluating the suitability of a process include: material type, material thickness, part geometry, required edge quality, throughput, tolerable le

If manufacturing your product requires cutting a shape out a sheet metal, you will face several processing options. Some factors to consider when evaluating the suitability of a process include: material type, material thickness, part geometry, required edge quality, throughput, tolerable level of heat input or mechanical force, dimensional tolerance, capital costs, and operating costs.
 

Learn More About Fiber Laser Cutting

The most popular traditional sheet metal techniques are shearing-type cutting (e.g. punching), waterjet, plasma, EDM, and lasers. Waterjet cutting was commonly used in industrial applications in the 1930s, while EDM and plasma cutting made their debuts in the 1960s. Laser cutting was introduced in the 1970s. It is difficult to date shearing-type cutting methods, as some of its variations go back to ancient times. the laser cutting was the largest segment of metal cutting machine sales in the world [1]. Comparing the cutting processes is the best way to understand what factors have been attracting a major number of fabricators to use lasers for cutting sheet metals. Instead of listing pros and cons for every process, here is a brief one-to-one comparison between cutting and the alternative process.

Shearing-type cutting methods

Cutting processes can be categorized into two main buckets in the way they extract the geometry: shearing-type cutting (e.g. punching), in which the entire geometry can be cut out of the sheet at once with mechanical force, and profile cutting techniques, where a cutting source draws the geometry like a pen (e.g. waterjet, plasma, EDM, lasers, etc.)

Punching vs. laser cutting

Punch cutting can be really fast, because in many cases the entire geometry can be carved out with a with a single hit. However, it requires large upfront tooling costs and therefore the production batch should be large enough to justify the cost. The mechanical forces used in punching can be limited by some geometrical features, such as thin webs. Some job shops working in an agile environment may be discouraged from punch cutting because of geometrical limitations (e.g. post-process burr removal.) 

Profile cutting processes use soft tooling to adapt to the changing designs at no fixed cost. Therefore, they unlock opportunities for manufacturers to prototype, run short-term and medium-term production, and maintain the low-volume customers that have the potential of mass production in the horizon. Fiber lasers have paved the path to high power industrial lasers becoming more affordable. More cost-effective technology as well as advances in automation are rapidly changing the equations for cross-over point of mass producing sheet metal parts, when one compares laser to punch. Many manufacturers have used laser cutting as a complementary process to punch mass production or replacing old punch machines with laser cutting machines.

Shearing-type cutting methods

This section discusses the major strong and weak performance points of profile cutting methods with a focus on sheet metal cutting rather than plate cutting, as the highest demand for cutting in the market is for sheet metals. Please note that thicknesses up to 0.5” (12 mm) are referred to as sheet metal whereas thicknesses more than 0.5” (12 mm) are named plates.

 图片.png

Waterjet vs. laser cutting

Waterjet machines are versatile in cutting both metals and non-metals. Waterjet is fundamentally a mechanical machining process, so for materials with higher hardness more cutting forces are needed and therefore cutting needs to slow down. Cutting metal require using abrasives in the waterjet, which comes with several challenges. These include nozzle wear, managing the accumulated abrasive pile, and running costs of abrasive powders. Interviewing the manufacturers doing sheet metal fabrication shows that the maintenance and particle/noise pollution are major complaints about waterjet cutting in a job shop environment. 

Waterjet cutting is flexible in terms of the range of materials and thicknesses it can cut; the material do not need to be conductive (unlike EDM or plasma) and can be quite thick (few inches with the right waterjet equipment.) However, fiber lasers provide faster cuts on sheet metals, typically with an order-of-magnitude narrower kerfs, 0.004” (100 µm) vs. 0.04” (1000 µm) They also require no maintenance or consumables, therefore making it the preferable production solution if the shop performs a lot of sheet metal cutting.

图片.png


EDM vs. laser cutting

Fabricators who use EDM have at least one thing in common; they need to meet very tight size tolerances, often few microns or smaller. EDM has satisfied the market for cutting high value parts made of thick metal (>0.5” [12 mm]) that needs to be taper-free, and require ultra-precise tolerances and sub-micron surface finish (e.g. die cutting.) However, EDM process is very slow by nature. Because the EDM process works by micro-arcing between a thin wire and the metal, you cannot go too fast before the wire shorts to the metal or trips by the arc being too strong. As a result, the cut speed cannot be significantly scaled up for thinner sheets, unlike laser cutting. Thin parts can be stacked up for batch EDM cutting to increase throughput, but pilot holes need to be pre-drilled on each part as pre-processing step to initiate EDM cuts. In that case, laser cutting can be a complementary process to pre-cut holes and cut the features that do not demand micron level accuracy. For the common range of sheet metal fabrication (0.01” [0.25 mm] to 0.5” [12 mm]), laser cutting is dramatically faster than EDM (even in its stacked-up version) and can maintain high accuracy for many applications.

图片.png

Plasma vs. laser cutting

Plasma cutting can be used for cutting metals, from thin sheets to thick plates (few inches, or tens of mm.) The cut kerf is generally wider than that of the laser kerf, and heat input into the part is significantly higher. Due to the wider kerf, higher heat input into the part, rougher/beveled cut surfaces in some cases, and variability due to nozzle degradation in long runs, plasma cutting is typically considered a less accurate method for cutting sheet metals, compared to lasers. The advantage of plasma cutting over laser has been historically in cutting thick plates and in low-cost cutting of less accurate sheet metal parts. But the rapid rise of fiber laser power at increasingly economical prices has shifted the boundary between the two processes year over year. For example, with 10-12 kW fiber laser systems , high quality, high speed cutting one 1 inch (25 mm) thick stainless steel, mild steel, and aluminum has been demonstrated. The cross-over thickness boundary between the two processes is expected to shift even more in the direction favoring fiber lasers in the foreseeable future. Available laser power continues to increase allowing for cutting of ever increasing thicknesses.

fiber plasma.jpg

图片.png

CO2 vs. fiber laser cutting

In recent years, laser cutting of sheet metals has been dominated by fiber laser. The main reasons include process reliability (no cut degradation due to the misalignment or contamination of mirrors), higher cutting speeds, the ability to cut reflective metals such as copper and brass, freedom from maintenance, and lower cost of ownership. CO2 lasers, however, have shown a smoother cut edge for some thicker materials (typically > 0.25” [6 mm]). This advantage is diminishing as advances in the high power fiber lasers and beam/gas delivery techniques are showing promises to close this gap.

图片.png

Is fiber laser cutting the right solution for your application?

Fiber laser systems have established their capability to cut metals at high quality and accommodate intricate geometries of parts, which are challenging to other processes. However, when it comes to final decision to purchase a fiber laser cutting machine, customers usually focus on the additional aspects that are specific to their case, including is a specific system is able to handle their parts’ tolerances and the question on if it is economical to use a specific fiber laser systems to product their parts. Below we discuss these two questions at a top level. 

Can fiber lasers handle your parts’ tolerances?

Factors such as kerf size, taper, surface roughness, heat input of the process, and the variability of the process during the long production runs eventually determine in practice if you can hold parts within a tight tolerance. Combination of small kerf, low heat input, good surface finish, and stable cutting makes fiber lasers a safe choice when it comes to cutting precise parts. The cutting precision partly depends on the motion system of the cutting machine. The SENYO Laser platform has complemented the inherent accuracy of fiber laser cutting with high accuracy motion system and look-ahead motion controls that achieve features with tolerance down to ± 0.001” (± µm).

Is fiber laser cutting economical for your project?

The capital costs and running costs of cutting processes are very different. Given the high speed and reliability of fiber lasers, and depending on the dosage of sheet metal cutting, they typically come ahead of other processes in terms of cost per part. In addition, fiber lasers have made economical parts that were not possible before (when using older generation of lasers or any other technique.) Availability of increasing laser power and wall-plug efficiency at a lower cost year after year will shift the cost calculation in favor of fiber laser cutting even more in the foreseeable future. SENYO is a small-footprint cost-effective cutting system that uses high-speed linear motors on a granite base to harness the high-speed cutting potentials of fiber lasers in sheet metal cutting.

Literature
[1] Metal Cutting Machine (MCM) Market Analysis, by Product (Laser, Waterjet, Plasma, Flame), by Application (Automotive, Aerospace & Defense, Construction, Marine, Electronics) and Segment Forecasts, 2014 – 2025, Research and Markets, Dublin, Ireland

Related Products
Module transmission customization Laser Marking Machine

Module transmission customization Laser Marking Machine

Half Enclosed Customized Semi Enclosed Tabletop Fiber Laser Marking Machine

Half Enclosed Customized Semi Enclosed Tabletop Fiber Laser Marking Machine

Flying Fiber Laser With Visual Positioning System CCD Camera Production Date PVC PE Pipe Marker Printer Marking Machine

Flying Fiber Laser With Visual Positioning System CCD Camera Production Date PVC PE Pipe Marker Printer Marking Machine

New Design Table design with 2d worktable Fiber Laser Marking Machine

New Design Table design with 2d worktable Fiber Laser Marking Machine

Handheld detachable laser marking machine for tire logo marking

Handheld detachable laser marking machine for tire logo marking

Table design Fiber laser marking engraving Metal Plastic Pcb Logo machine

Table design Fiber laser marking engraving Metal Plastic Pcb Logo machine

Full Closed Type Fiber Laser Marking Machine High Safety Color Metal Laser Jewelry Engraving

Full Closed Type Fiber Laser Marking Machine High Safety Color Metal Laser Jewelry Engraving

1325 3 Axis 4x8 CNC Stone Router for Sale

1325 3 Axis 4x8 CNC Stone Router for Sale

Wood Marking Glass Marking RF Co2 Laser Marking Machine for Non Metal

Wood Marking Glass Marking RF Co2 Laser Marking Machine for Non Metal

CO2 Metal Pipe Marking Ceramic, Rubber,PVC,PPC,Acrylic.

CO2 Metal Pipe Marking Ceramic, Rubber,PVC,PPC,Acrylic.

Co2 Laser Marking Machine for Non Metal Low Cost

Co2 Laser Marking Machine for Non Metal Low Cost

High efficiency Multi Head Rotary 4 Axis 3d Wood CNC Router Machine

High efficiency Multi Head Rotary 4 Axis 3d Wood CNC Router Machine

Auto feeding fabric leather cloth laser cutter cutting machine for garment industry

Auto feeding fabric leather cloth laser cutter cutting machine for garment industry

3020 40W Mini CO2 Laser Engraving Cutting Machine

3020 40W Mini CO2 Laser Engraving Cutting Machine

Stone CNC Router Engraving Granite Machine One Holder Two Spindle

Stone CNC Router Engraving Granite Machine One Holder Two Spindle

Vertical diamond rope single wire rope Marble and Granite Stone Cutting Machine

Vertical diamond rope single wire rope Marble and Granite Stone Cutting Machine

Stone Profiling Line Polishing and Kitchen Granite Marble Polisher Edge Machinery

Stone Profiling Line Polishing and Kitchen Granite Marble Polisher Edge Machinery

Wood and Metal Aluminum Cutting CNC Router

Wood and Metal Aluminum Cutting CNC Router

Four Surface Sanding  Automatic Mechanical Polishing Machine

Four Surface Sanding Automatic Mechanical Polishing Machine

3D CNC Router Woodworking Machine 8 heads with 4 axis Rotary

3D CNC Router Woodworking Machine 8 heads with 4 axis Rotary

Door Furniture Line Making Machine Automatic Loading Unloading ATC CNC Router

Door Furniture Line Making Machine Automatic Loading Unloading ATC CNC Router

Wood Board Side Sander Brush Sanding Polishing Machine

Wood Board Side Sander Brush Sanding Polishing Machine

High Z axis Styrofoam carving cnc router 4 axis foam cutting machine

High Z axis Styrofoam carving cnc router 4 axis foam cutting machine

Woodworking Furniture 4 Spindle Atc Cnc Router Machine

Woodworking Furniture 4 Spindle Atc Cnc Router Machine

3D CNC Router With Rotary 4axis Caving

3D CNC Router With Rotary 4axis Caving

Three Independent Head CNC Router Machine

Three Independent Head CNC Router Machine

CO2 Laser Metal & Non Metal Cutting Machine

CO2 Laser Metal & Non Metal Cutting Machine

8 Spindles Multi Heads CNC Router wood carving machine

8 Spindles Multi Heads CNC Router wood carving machine

Automatic Combination Door Cabinet Wood Disc Brush Polish Sanding Sander Machine

Automatic Combination Door Cabinet Wood Disc Brush Polish Sanding Sander Machine

Metal laser cutter CNC fiber laser cutting machine sheet metal

Metal laser cutter CNC fiber laser cutting machine sheet metal

>
<
···
Related Videos
>
<
···
Related Projects
The Apprentice Maze Puzzle Box

The Apprentice Maze Puzzle Box

Box laser cutting software share

Box laser cutting software share

laser marking and engraving for the jewelry industry

laser marking and engraving for the jewelry industry

Copper cutting for fiber laser cutting machine

Copper cutting for fiber laser cutting machine

Aluminum Cutting for fiber laser cutting machine

Aluminum Cutting for fiber laser cutting machine

CS Laser Cutting Factors that Affect the Process

CS Laser Cutting Factors that Affect the Process

Stainless steel Fiber Laser Cutting

Stainless steel Fiber Laser Cutting

2d&3d wood MDF carving and cutting

2d&3d wood MDF carving and cutting

3D CNC Router for Stone Relief Carving Projects

3D CNC Router for Stone Relief Carving Projects

Typical fields of application

Typical fields of application

UV Laser Marking Machine For Glasses Engraving

UV Laser Marking Machine For Glasses Engraving

GOLD Engraving -Fiber laser marking work

GOLD Engraving -Fiber laser marking work

Sover Engraving -Fiber metal engraving and marking

Sover Engraving -Fiber metal engraving and marking

3D Marking Logo deep engraving -Fiber marking machine

3D Marking Logo deep engraving -Fiber marking machine

MOPA Fiber Laser Marking Machine Application and Samples

MOPA Fiber Laser Marking Machine Application and Samples

Fiber Laser Engraving and Marking Machine for Metalworking Projects

Fiber Laser Engraving and Marking Machine for Metalworking Projects

Stone shaft Rotary use engrave cnc router machine

Stone shaft Rotary use engrave cnc router machine

CNC Knife Cutter for PVC Soft Glass

CNC Knife Cutter for PVC Soft Glass

Foam cutting use CNC Routers

Foam cutting use CNC Routers

Laser Engraving Machine for Jewelry

Laser Engraving Machine for Jewelry

Laser Cutting Sheet Metal

Laser Cutting Sheet Metal

Synagogue Temple Marble Cutting and Engraving

Synagogue Temple Marble Cutting and Engraving

Projects fabricated for Ceramics engraving

Projects fabricated for Ceramics engraving

Leather Laser Cutting and Laser Engraving

Leather Laser Cutting and Laser Engraving

Fabric & Textile Laser Cutting and Laser Engraving

Fabric & Textile Laser Cutting and Laser Engraving

Laser Engrave Candle Stamps

Laser Engrave Candle Stamps

Wedding Planing and Laser Cutting Paper

Wedding Planing and Laser Cutting Paper

Making Letter Signs double color plate and acrylic

Making Letter Signs double color plate and acrylic

Acrylic glass engraving-- CNC Router

Acrylic glass engraving-- CNC Router

Engraving Copper and brass of signs, nameplates and name tags

Engraving Copper and brass of signs, nameplates and name tags

>
<
···
leave a message
  • *Your Name:

  • *Your Email:

  • *Product:

  • *Your Requirements:

  • Most Helpful Reviews

    Jacob from United States

    I am a beginner at CNC, I’ve never used a CNC machine before and with in a day I was carving. An awesome machine for a beginner to learn as hobbyists. I used the manual and the help video. One hour to assemble and test, very friendly and easy to use. It’s a good buy for the money. I would definitely recommend this machine to someone getting into CNCs.

    Weinstein from France

    I've been using CNC plasma SYP2060-300A and I am very impressed with this unit.

    This unit is of higher quality, made in China. Five stars all the way!

    1530 CNC Plasma from Australia

    This CNC plasma cuts very easy Very good machine .

    But I also recommend purchasing the nozzles and the tips of the torch  consumables oarts they wear out quickly and for a good operation they must be in good condition.  

    Laser welding machine Franklin White​ from

    These are some great information that you have shared herechoosing the right laser welding machine.I really loved it and thank you very much for sharing this with us. You have a great visualization and you have really presented this content in a really good manner.

    Fiber Laser 3000W from UK

    Thanks for SYJF1530-3000W , The machine runs fast and the cutting effect is good. Fiber laser 1530 meet our job requirements. Thank you on behalf of my business!

    5 axis cnc router machine works very good from UK

    We bought An 5 axis cnc router . 5axis CNC routers are popular amongst universities to produce 2D and 3D objects from wood, plastics, foam and many more materials.

    Universities and schools across the world have produced many prototypes using their CNC machines. CNC routers are popular in architecture,

    woodworking, physics and engineering, for projects and research and development.

    CNC Router ATC tool changer 1325 from Bangladesh

    We bought ATC Tool changer SYM1325-ATC 2018.9 , ATC tool changer for my company

    It main working for furniture works , Every day use it work 15 hours , and it really work nice . The sales manager is  very nice person

    I really love that machine . High recommand !

    Maldonado from Mexico

    IPG 3000W 3015 Fiber metal laser cutter we have ever purchased.
    For 10 hours daily working, it still keeps the high precision and the high working speed. I really love it.

    Francisco from Portugal

    A máquina CNC funciona muito bem.

    A fresadora CNC 1325 é uma unidade bem feita e não encontrei problemas com a qualidade de construção ou operação.

    Daisuke from Japan

    It is still working well since I purchased it. The PTP working center is really convinient machine for my wood work, I am happy to give the 5 stars to this one! Original source from https://www.stylecnc.com, if you want to copy, please indicate the primary source: https://www.stylecnc.com/cnc-working-center/PTP-all-rounder-CNC-working-center.html
    It is still working well since I purchased it. The PTP working center is really convinient machine for my wood work, I am happy to give the 5 stars to this one! Original source from https://www.stylecnc.com, if you want to copy, please indicate the primary source: https://www.stylecnc.com/cnc-working-center/PTP-all-rounder-CNC-working-center.html

    It is still working well since I purchased it.

    The Wood working center is really convinient machine for my wood work, I am happy to give the 5 stars to this ! 

    manager@senyocnc.com SENYOCNC +8615253141880 +8615253141880 2061579344